EX-009 · Pursuits & standoffs
Camp Sweep Standoff: 'What Are You Arresting Me For?'
What happens when nobody blinks?
Salt Lake City Police DepartmentUtahLibrary Square, Salt Lake CityIncident: January 1, 202010:58
Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube
What happened
On New Year's Day 2020, Salt Lake City police were enforcing the city's camping ordinance at Library Square while a group filmed. Bodycam-style footage shows a step-back order, a fight over whether shelter beds were available, and an arrest. According to FOX 13, police said the man was arrested for interfering with an arrest and resisting arrest. Those are allegations, and no court outcome was found. We break down the order, the arguments, and what to do differently. Footage: Salt Lake City Police Department release. News source: FOX 13, Jan 2, 2020.
The law in plain English
Interfering with an arresting officer (Utah; specific code section not confirmed)
Offense of obstructing or interfering with an officer while they are making an arrest. Police cited it for this arrest.
Resisting arrest (Utah; specific code section not confirmed)
Offense of resisting or refusing to cooperate with an officer's effort to take a person into custody. Police cited it for this arrest.
General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.
Lessons
Comply now, dispute later
If you disagree with an order, step back and challenge it afterward through a complaint or in court. The scene is not the place to win the legal argument.
Stay still, ask calmly
Struggling gives officers a reason to use more force and add charges. Ask what you're being arrested for in a steady voice, then raise the legal dispute later with a lawyer.
Complain in writing, afterward
Ask for a supervisor politely, note names and badge numbers, and take your concerns to the department or oversight body afterward. A written record travels farther than a shouting match.
Your call
At the moment of the grab, was 'step back' clear enough, or should officers repeat it before touching someone?
Answer in the YouTube commentsFull transcript (232 lines)
There are. Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey. What the hell? What the hell? What the hell?
New Year's Day, Salt Lake City.
Officers are clearing a camp.
A crowd with cameras says the shelters are full.
Officers say step back.
What happens when nobody blinks?
Prediction time. Does anyone leave in handcuffs?
Comment Y for yes, N for no.
And smash like if you've ever argued over a dictionary definition mid-argument.
Ma'am. Ma'am.
Can you step back?
Well, I'm not going. Why are you guys doing this?
We're closing off this area. Closing off this area?
Courting. Courting? Are you aware of the definition of courting?
Cordon. Cordon? Cordon.
I don't know what a cordon is.
So why are you making this accessible?
That's the opening.
A woman is asked to step back, and she asks why.
An officer says the area is being closed off.
Then comes a pop quiz on the word cordon...
<chuckle> Nobody studied.
According to FOX 13, police said officers were enforcing the city's camping
ordinance at Library Square.
In the next clip, listen for the reasons the officer gives.
Protecting lives.
We've been in a huge area where these people are subjecting themselves to harmful
situations.
We've offered them rides to the shelter, which is open.
Which is open?
They have transporters come over with vans.
I know personally I've offered a couple rides today and they said no thank you.
No.
Because they don't like me?
Yeah.
Because they don't like me?
Okay. I get that.
So...
What's it, badge stands for? My badge stands.
The officer's reasons so far: enforcing the no camping ordinance, protecting lives,
and rides offered to a shelter.
The people on camera say there are no beds.
The footage can't settle that on its own.
Now, back to the moment from our opening.
Listen for the explanation right after the grab.
It starts with 'we've told her to step back.'
Problem. Why can't we step here? You guys are wanting the problem, okay? There are
Shelter beds available. We're standing here. There are plenty. There's multiple new
There's always beds available at the overflow, okay? At the overflow? At the
overflow. Really?
St. Vinny's? Yes. Guess what? Fifty-eight spots. Okay. There's not always beds
available
There. We've been there in person. Okay. So what's your next bullshit line? Guys.
No, no. Give us another line. Tell us something else. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay.
Because we've done. We're going to stand here. You guys can stand there, okay? We've
There. Don't walk over here. Why are you bouncing people? They have asked us to and
It's illegal. Who's they? Okay. Who's they? The city, our department. Who would the
Ask you? Who? Give us a name. Salt Lake City. What person with the city? Hires the
Notice the officer's framing.
In his words, the order was given and not followed.
Then the argument jumps back to beds.
Someone says fifty-eight spots.
Someone else says they were there in person.
Two claims, zero spreadsheets.
Next clip, a speaker cites Martin v.
City of Boise. That's their claim about the law.
Whether it applies here is for courts, not for us.
Complaint later. Don't worry. I am filming, motherfucker. I know. You guys have been
It for a long time. So let me ask you something. This is the 10th Circuit. Under
persuasive
Authority from the 9th Circuit's ruling in Martin v. City of Boise, which I know you
Know because I told your fucking colleagues that the other day. Hey. Why are you
arresting
Her? Hey. Why are you arresting her? You can't. You can't arrest her for no reason.
They've
Got warrants. Really? So you came out here and are just fucking with people more?
With people more? No. You came out here and are just fucking with people more? You
Out here and are just fucking with people more? No. You came out here and are just
With people more? No. You came out here and are just fucking with people more? No.
Didn't come out here to arrest people. You didn't come out here to clean up shit.
A traffic warrant. You're cuffing someone for a traffic warrant. Why is he being
arrested?
Listen to the answer to 'why are you arresting her.' An officer says, 'They've got
warrants.' In general, an officer who confirms a valid warrant can arrest on it,
even for something like a traffic matter.
Separately, people on camera argue that asking for names had no cause.
That's a legal question the footage doesn't decide.
Next, watch how people ask for a supervisor.
We get your stuff? What I'm stopping for? Who is the highest ranking officer here?
Uh, him. Kay. Hey! Are you the highest ranking officer
Here? Is it the blue tart? Yes. Who is the highest ranking officer here?
It's right here, sorry. Kay, cool. Get your fucking boss down here.
No? No? Yeah. Okay, get your commander, get the watch commander down here. Okay,
Breaking the law, motherfucker. Yes you are. The ten circuit is under persuasive
authority
From the ninth circuit ruling that says you can't come out here without a badge.
9th Circuit ruling that says you cannot, no, you can't break these camps up.
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 armed cops arresting people.
You're not listening to me.
I'm telling you the law.
10th Circuit is under persuasive authority from the 9th Circuit's ruling.
So that's fantastic.
We wouldn't need all these guys if you guys didn't cause the problem.
Let's be fair. Something officers did well: they kept answering questions while
being cursed at, and an officer explained their numbers when asked.
Something a viewer could question: the grab came while the conversation was still
going. Both are observations, not verdicts.
Next clip, listen for the words 'lawful order' and 'stop resisting.'
I'm giving you a lawful order now.
You need to justify it with a law.
Because we're doing an investigation right now.
Of what?
This is your choice.
I'm not doing anything.
Stop resisting.
What are you arresting me for?
Stop resisting.
I got left.
Go to the ground.
I got left.
Okay.
Just take him down.
Okay.
Give up your hands now.
Give up your hands.
I got a taser if you need it.
Give up your hands.
That's the turn. An officer says he's giving a lawful order and that they're doing
an investigation. The man asks, of what?
Then comes 'stop resisting' and a takedown.
Watch the next clip.
After the cuffs, the man asks again and again what he's being arrested for.
Pay attention to how the officer answers.
You had the choice.
You could have moved back.
I had the choice?
What did you arrest me for?
Fuck you.
Fuck you, motherfucker.
What did you arrest me for?
Relax.
Tell me what you arrested me for.
Relax.
Hey, tell me what you arrested me for.
Relax.
Motherfucker, get the fuck off me.
Get the fuck off me.
Tell me what you arrested me for.
This is all we got left.
Let us take this shit out of here.
Tell me what you arrested me for.
You were given a lawful order to back up.
How can you give me a lawful order to lease public property?
You were given a lawful order to step back while we conducted an investigation.
Investigation of what?
And you refused.
Investigation of what?
Hey, man.
You're not listening.
What were you investigating?
Illegal camping.
There's the decision of illegal camping.
This isn't illegal camping.
And then we needed some space.
This is not.
So we asked you to get back.
No.
You're watching Struggle Ash.
We pause the footage so you can learn the rules without living them.
Subscribe, it's free, and so is hindsight.
Yeah, sounds like it.
Yeah, I think we're fine.
If I need to go, just
Sit on his legs.
Hey, we're good here.
Just go on his legs, yeah?
Two ideas in plain English.
A lawful order: officers can generally direct people to move during an
investigation, and refusing can lead to a charge like interfering with an arresting
officer. Whether an order was lawful gets decided later.
Resisting arrest is separate: not cooperating with being taken into custody.
So we asked you to get back and you refused.
This is not illegal camping.
And then you resisted arrest.
You can't camp illegally when there's no shelter.
Look, man, this is what you want.
You see what I want?
Yes, this is what you want.
Are you going to cooperate or are you going to freak out again?
Lesson one. Comply now, dispute later.
In the clip, the officer says the step-back order was refused.
Whether it was lawful is a later question.
If you disagree, you can challenge it afterward, through a complaint or in court.
The sidewalk is a terrible courtroom.
Fuck you, dude.
Fuck you.
This is making it worse.
You motherfuckers are making it worse.
Lesson two. Once hands are on you, stay still and ask calmly what the arrest is for.
General practice: officers are trained to treat struggling as a risk.
Listen to the exchange.
An officer says 'it's just going to make it worse.' Keep that in mind when
adrenaline is high.
Where's your motherfucking watch commander?
Who's the watch commander?
You, you little stupid ass ain't shit.
Lesson three. Asking for a supervisor is allowed.
Note names and badge numbers, then file a complaint in writing afterward.
Yelling at the line rarely gets a commander faster.
In the next clip, listen for an officer's view on filming.
This is now this is all their choice.
They would not be thrown on the ground.
They just back up film all you want, you know?
Alright, Y people and N people, here's how it went.
If you learned something, like and subscribe for the next case.
Is that OK? OK good.
You got her.
According to FOX 13, police arrested one man and said it was for interfering with an
arrest and resisting arrest.
The paper described him as a member of the group CivilRiot.
These are allegations only.
No plea, ruling, or sentence appears in the sources reviewed, so the outcome isn't
public yet.
I wonder how they have so much information on what we have to do.
So they park right over here,
And they stay there all night.
FOX 13 reports police said the man was held for interfering with and resisting
arrest. No court outcome is public.
Takeaway: argue the law afterward, not at arm's length.
Was the grab right after the step-back request fair, or too fast?
That's the debrief.
Stay out of the struggle.



