EX-019 · DUI stops
CHP Officer vs Driver: The 'Can I Refuse?' Argument
Out on Highway 101 near Crescent City, a driver and a CHP officer argue that exact question for over a dozen minutes, and we're grading both.
California Highway PatrolCaliforniaHighway 101, near Crescent City8:50
Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube
What happened
A California Highway Patrol officer detains a driver near Crescent City after a 911 report of a swerving white Dodge Ram on Highway 101. The driver repeatedly asks whether he can refuse an eye check, and the officer's answers shift. We grade the key decisions on both sides of the window as textbook moves, rookie mistakes and one judgment call. Charges and any court result are not public in the material provided. Footage: Police Transparency, an agency bodycam release. General information only, not legal advice.
The law in plain English
Detention vs. arrest
Detaining someone to investigate generally needs less justification than arresting them. Consequences of refusing tests, such as the license suspension this officer describes, vary by state. Courts decide later whether each step was lawful.
General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.
Lessons
Roadside debates settle nothing
A roadside argument rarely resolves a legal question. Courts decide later who was right. Short, calm statements put your position on record without raising the temperature for anyone, officers included.
Say what you know, early and calm
A brief, calm account can shorten a stop, but whether to answer questions is a personal decision. What helps either way is a steady tone and knowing the difference between calm and silent.
Your call
The officer said 'Yeah, you can' refuse, then said 'Turn around.' Was that the right place to draw the line?
Answer in the YouTube commentsFull transcript (202 lines)
Walk away.
You're going to go down to the ground.
Can you refuse a roadside eye check?
Most people answer fast and sure.
Out on Highway 101 near Crescent City, a driver and a CHP officer argue that exact
question for over a dozen minutes, and we're grading both.
Gut check before we grade a thing: was the arrest justified?
Type Y or N below, and tap like if you've ever lost an argument to a search bar.
You're being detained at this moment, you understand that?
To see if you're okay to drive, alright?
Alright, alright dude, you're gonna hold on.
Alright, it's not your show, okay?
What's that?
It's not your show, dude.
Alright, you're gonna tell me what to do.
So you're gonna put your food down on the roof?
No, you need to call your supervisor if you're gonna be acting all crazy.
You're gonna put your stuff down real quick, dude?
Put your stuff down?
You can't do this to me.
I just wanna make sure if you're okay to drive.
Okay, I'm gonna see if you're okay to drive, dude.
First grade. A 911 caller reported a white Dodge Ram swerving and nearly causing a
collision. The officer tells the driver he's detained and says why: to see if he's
okay to drive. Plain reason, plain words.
Then he asks for ID and gets it.
<chuckle> Textbook.
Next, listen to how straight he is with his sergeant.
He's making everything a big deal.
I don't think he's drunk.
Let me check his eyes.
No, no, he was parked.
I just came up here when he was parked there, because he was parked at the White
Lakers,
So he parked there at Subway.
So I didn't see him driving at all, or not yet.
Second textbook move: he calls a supervisor, and he's honest.
He says he didn't see the driving himself, relays the 911 report, and says, quote, I
don't think he's drunk.
A bit later he asks whether to kick him loose or go to 148.
Next clip, listen for what the word refuse does to this stop.
You got, man.
I'm just trying to check your eyes, bro.
If you're not drunk, you're leaving out of here.
I just want to check your eyes.
How are you going to tell if I'm drunk by my eyes?
Well, that's why we do all these tests.
No, I'm not doing all that BS, man.
I just want to check your eyes, and everything checks out.
You see what I mean?
I can refuse.
If you refuse, then I have to arrest you for refusing.
No, that's not true.
Yes, it is, man.
I'm trying to be cool with you.
I don't even know you.
Man, I know.
I work for the law.
What are you going to tell me to look up?
No, you cannot arrest me for refusing.
I can arrest you for, yes.
Okay, let me see.
Google it.
No, I'm not going to waste my time on Google stuff.
Rookie mistake, and everyone shares it.
The driver says he can refuse.
The officer says refusing means arrest.
Minutes later the officer says you can refuse, but it raises his suspicion.
The driver offers to Google it, and the question never gets settled on camera.
Two grown adults, one unanswered question, zero Googling.
So I'm refusing.
Is that illegal?
So I want to check your eyes, man.
I'm refusing.
Is that illegal?
It's illegal.
If you don't, if you want to, if, okay.
Let me grab my phone and I'll check if it's illegal, then I will cooperate a hundred
percent.
So at this point, dude, if you're not going to do it, I'm going to have to arrest
For 148.
Ask these guys.
No, I'm not going to ask them nothing.
I'm asking, I'm telling you, do you want to do it?
At this point, I'm done talking.
We spent a lot of time talking.
I'm not calling you.
You had your chance.
You don't let him talk.
Call the sergeant.
This guy's tripping.
He's trying to stop my ride.
I'm going to tell you one more time.
Are you going to let me check your eyes?
Are you going to let me check?
Can I legally refuse?
Yeah, you can.
Judgment call. The driver says he'll cooperate a hundred percent once he checks his
phone. The officer says he'll arrest for 148.
Then comes the same question: can I legally refuse?
Officer: Yeah, you can.
But at this point, I'm asking you.
Seconds later he says turn around.
Fair line, or too fast?
Reasonable people split.
Next, after the cuffs, listen to why the Glock gets taken.
We're taking your Glock and your rifles, okay?
What for?
For the Glock.
You can't have it ready accessible with a loaded mag next to your incident console.
You understand?
That's supposed to be safe, pretty much apart.
The gun in one place, the mag in another place.
So, we're taking that for evidence, okay?
Your rifles, they're going to be for safekeeping.
So, you can go to the office when you get out.
Go pick up your rifles.
Struggle Ash brings you real stops with a scorecard attached.
Subscribe, and let somebody else take the failing grade.
So, can you submit to a blood draw and make sure you're not under the influence of
I ain't submitting nothing like that.
If not, I'm going to have to go through a refusal.
And if you want to do a refusal, they're going to suspend your license.
So, it would be better if you submit to a chemical blood draw.
Do you understand that or not?
Yeah, I do.
So, it's up to you.
If you don't want to, like you've been refusing everything else, I'm going to read
you this,
And then I'm going to do a warrant for your blood, okay?
And it's going to suspend your license for a couple years.
Do you understand that?
I do understand that, yeah.
So, do you want to submit to a chemical blood draw?
Third textbook move: a clear choice.
Submit to a blood draw, or the officer says he'll read a refusal admonition and seek
a warrant, with a license suspension to follow, in his words.
He asks if the driver understands.
The driver says yes, then agrees to the draw.
Clear options, clear consequences.
Now listen for when the driver finally tells his side.
He turned into my lane because the passing lane was getting ready to end.
But I kept going, and he went into my lane before it was over.
But I was already...
He was already on his butt, ready to pass.
And he was in the right lane, and I was coming up on the left lane.
And then he got over, and I had to go around him.
And they honked, and it was crazy, but...
What happened?
No, they didn't see me in the mirror.
So, why can't you just tell me all this from the start, bro?
Rookie mistake candidate for the driver, and a fair question for the stop itself.
Over half an hour in, he describes a lane change as a passing lane was ending.
That's his unverified version.
The officer asks why not say that from the start.
The driver says he didn't need to.
The driver also says he thinks CHP assumes he's drunk because he's Native.
The officer says that's not the case.
Have you drank, you haven't had, have you had anything to drink?
I can refuse.
Have you had anything to drink?
I can refuse for you to check my eyes.
Okay, I'm asking you a question.
All right, Sarge, I'll call you back.
Can I refuse?
Hey, ask him.
Ask him if I can refuse.
Yeah, but then again, that gives me suspicion that you are drunk.
So, have you drank anything at all?
How the rules frame the grading, in general terms.
Detaining someone and arresting them generally require different levels of
justification, and rules on refusal vary by state.
Courts, not roadside arguments, decide whether a detention or arrest was lawful.
Check your own state's law.
I can refuse, man.
So now you're impeding with my investigation, dude.
No, I can refuse.
I can legally refuse.
Is that yes or no?
No, you can't, dude.
Remember your Y or N on the arrest?
Hold that thought, the scorecard is next.
Like if you called it, and subscribe for the next case.
So, I asked you if it was illegal if I refused.
You said it wasn't.
Scorecard. Officer: a stated reason for the detention, an honest supervisor call, a
clear blood draw choice.
One rookie mistake: mixed answers on refusal.
Driver: handed over ID and agreed to the blood draw, but held back his account for a
long stretch. The arrest stays a judgment call.
On camera the officer says the driver was arrested, with 148 mentioned.
Charges as filed and any court result are not public yet.
The way you're acting, your eyes are watery.
How am I supposed to make sure that you're not drunk?
That's my job to take people that are drunk off the road.
Can we pause right there?
So, I asked you...
Is this debating what?
Takeaway: a calm question beats a loud argument, on both sides of the window.
Right call or wrong call: the officer saying Yeah, you can, then telling him to turn
around? That's the debrief.
Stay out of the struggle.



