Struggle Ash Subscribe

Home / Episodes / San Francisco Police Department

EX-020 · Pursuits & standoffs

Officers Chase Driver Who Allegedly Threw Pipe Bombs

One chase, about thirty minutes, zero chill.

San Francisco Police DepartmentCaliforniaSan Francisco to MartinezIncident: October 29, 20238:45

Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube

What happened

On October 29, 2023, San Francisco officers chased a driver who allegedly threw explosive devices at them after an assault at a North Beach church. We pause the SFPD footage at three decision points, the stop, the first blast, and the highway, and explain what the alternatives were. We also cover the California attempted murder statutes and two takeaways for viewers. All charges are allegations and the case is pending. Footage: San Francisco Police Department Medal of Valor release.

The law in plain English

Cal. Penal Code 664

Punishes someone who tries to commit a crime but fails; attempted premeditated murder can carry life in state prison with possibility of parole.

Cal. Penal Code 187

Defines murder as the unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought; attempted murder pairs this with section 664.

General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.

Lessons

  1. A slowdown is not a stop

    If you see lights, signal, pull over and stop completely. Slowing and rolling can read as not complying. Stop fully, hands visible, and follow commands.

  2. Details shorten the chase

    Witnesses who give the car, the direction and what happened help officers act fast. Dispatch relaying threats to other agencies keeps responders from being surprised.

Your call

When the second device landed at Eighth and Mission, should officers have kept chasing or backed off and tracked from a distance?

Answer in the YouTube comments
Full transcript (133 lines)

Driver's side window where it landed between their two vehicles.

Pop quiz. A car slows down right after your lights and sirens come on.

Do you relax? According to the department, three San Francisco officers were about

to learn why not. One chase, about thirty minutes, zero chill.

There has been an assault of a prisoner and the assailant has escaped and he crossed

Columbus.

On Sunday, October 29th, 2023, at 1752 hours, Officer Sam Nguyen, Juan Lora, and

Brian Neuerberg

Responded to St. Peter's and Paul Church where an attempted robbery and aggravated

Assault had just occurred.

Sunday, October 29th, 2023, 5:52 in the evening.

According to the SFPD release, three officers respond to Saints Peter and Paul

Church after an attempted robbery and aggravated assault.

The AP reports a man allegedly punched a parishioner during Mass.

Witnesses follow the suspect to his parked BMW, and the first officer arrives as it

is driving away. In the next clip, listen for how fast the witnesses point him out.

Witnesses followed the suspect to his parked BMW.

As the suspect was driving away, Officer Nguyen arrived on scene and witnesses

immediately

Pointed to the BMW.

Lock in a call: does this stop end without a bang?

Type Y or N below, and tap like if you've ever trusted a slow car.

Next clip, watch how the BMW slows.

Officer Nguyen activated the car.

Officer Nguyen activated his red-blue emergency lights, sirens, and utilized his PA

To tell the driver to pull over.

At that moment, it appeared that the suspect was submitting to the officer's lawful

By slowing down.

Unbeknownst to the officers, the suspect was baiting the officers to get closer.

Three moments decided how this night went.

We count down. Moment three: the stop.

According to the department, officers used lights, sirens and the PA, and the driver

slowed as if submitting.

Then, allegedly, he threw an IED that landed between the two cars.

Slowing down is not pulling over.

<chuckle> The fork: close in on a car that has not stopped, or hold back.

They planned a high-risk stop first, which is good.

How close was close enough?

Fair question.

Don't come down until 9.33.

Make sure that you just throw something out and just explode."

Officer Nguyen, Lora and Neuerberg described feeling the blast pressure from the

bomb as

It exploded.

Moment two. All three officers described feeling the blast pressure.

According to the SFPD release, they realized this was not a typical robbery suspect,

and could not rule out the church as a target.

<sigh> Not a typical robbery suspect.

Understatement of the year.

The fork: break off, or stay on him.

They stayed, and one officer kept broadcasting the pursuit the whole way.

Stronger move or bigger risk?

Both are fair. Next clip: listen for the radio call at Hyde.

The pursuit ascended and descended Knob Hill in the heart of San Francisco.

Officers Yuen and Laura tactically chased the suspect through some of the busiest

streets in the city,

While Officer Nuremberg maintained continuous broadcasts of the pursuit in flawless

fashion.

Approaching Hyde. Now it's going to go southbound Hyde.

When the pursuit reached Hyde and O'Farrell Street,

The suspect held out another IED out of the driver's side window

And ran a red light before lighting and throwing the second IED

At the intersection of 8th Street and Mission Street.

We're going to be southbound through Mission Street.

Oh! He just threw another bomb.

He just blew up on Mission.

Moment one, the biggest fork.

The audio catches the second device, allegedly thrown at Eighth and Mission after a

red light. The SF Chronicle reports police said no injuries or property damage

resulted. Then the driver heads onto Interstate 80.

The fork: call it off with explosives possibly in the car, or stay on.

According to the SFPD, the officers stayed.

Watch the next clip for the driver reaching toward the passenger floorboard.

The officers believed another device was there and prepared for possible deadly

force.

At times during the pursuit, the officers could see the suspect reaching for

something

In the passenger side floorboard as he periodically swerved and slowed down.

The officers believed that the suspect had an additional IED

And prepared themselves for the possibility of another IED being used against them

And the possibility they would have to use deadly force.

Struggle Ash puts the pause button on real police chaos so you can see the fork in

the road coming. Subscribe, it's free.

And please notify CHP if they do set up spikes, he does have explosives.

Dispatch relaying this vital information to the California Highway Patrol,

Who caught up to the pursuing officers near Walnut Creek,

To go over the pursuit.

In California, attempted murder pairs Penal Code 187, the definition of murder, with

section 664, which punishes trying a crime and failing.

Booked on suspicion is not convicted.

Prosecutors still have to prove every charge in court.

Officers Lora and Neuerberg soon after arrived on scene and they began to coordinate

a high-risk

Lesson one: a slowdown is not a stop.

If you see lights, signal, pull over, and stop completely.

Slowing and rolling can read as not complying.

In this replay, listen for the words high-risk traffic stop.

Officers coordinated that before anyone moved in, which is what they did well.

A high-risk stop is a planned stop, with commands given from a distance.

That's general practice, not advice for anyone's case.

Attempting to rob someone at a church and having an IED, officers could not discount

That the suspect could be a fanatic and the church, a target.

Lesson two: information is a safety tool.

In that replay, officers say they could not rule out the church as a target.

Earlier, witnesses followed the suspect to the BMW and pointed it out as an officer

arrived. Dispatch also warned CHP about explosives in case spikes were set up.

If you ever witness a crime, call it in with the car, the direction and what you

saw. Details shorten chases.

And willfully continued the pursuit as the suspect entered eastbound Interstate 80.

Scoreboard check: if you said N on the quiet stop, you win, and nobody's happy about

it. Subscribe for the next case.

The pursuit continued for a few more miles until the suspect's tire was damaged,

crippling the BMW.

The suspect then exited his vehicle and immediately surrendered.

A search of the BMW by the bomb squad located and destroyed a third IED found on the

front passenger side floorboard,

According to the SFPD release, the driver's tire was damaged, crippling the BMW, and

he exited and surrendered.

The bomb squad found and destroyed a third device on the passenger floorboard.

The AP reports he was booked on suspicion of attempted murder, unlawful possession

of an explosive device and other crimes.

Prosecutors told the AP he pleaded not guilty to a dozen charges.

A verdict or sentence is not public yet.

The SFPD then awarded the three officers its Gold Medal of Valor.

For their bravery and outstanding performance under a once-in-a-lifetime incident,

I am proud to award Officer Sam Yuen, Officer Juan Lara, and Brian Nuremberg the

Gold Medal of Valor.

Per the AP, the case is pending after a not-guilty plea.

Takeaway: a slowing car is not a stopped car, and a witness's details start

everything. Tell me your verdict: when the second device hit Mission Street, should

those officers have kept chasing?

That's the debrief.

Stay out of the struggle.

Related episodes