Struggle Ash Subscribe

Home / Episodes / Agency not identified

EX-021 · DUI stops

The Felony Spit Law, Explained With Real Texas Bodycam

Today: one statute, tested against the footage.

Agency not identifiedTexasHector, TexasIncident: Sept. 16, 20228:47

Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube

What happened

Texas bodycam from a September 2022 stop: a woman in a wrecked Dodge Charger says a black truck chased her, and the encounter ends in an arrest. We use the footage to explain Tex. Penal Code 22.11 (harassment of a public servant) and how implied-consent warnings work, as general information only. Charges are allegations, not convictions. Local reporting from the Odessa American describes a case that appears to match; we could not confirm it is the same incident. Footage credit: Police Transparency.

The law in plain English

Tex. Penal Code 22.11

Causing a person you know is a public servant, such as an officer, to contact your saliva, blood, urine or feces while on duty, with intent to harass, alarm or assault, is a third-degree felony.

General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.

Lessons

  1. Keep requests short and clear

    Ask plainly for medical help, a lawyer, or whether you're free to go. Insults and shouting just become lines in a report.

  2. Never put bodily fluids near officers

    In many states, contact with an officer's body can turn a bad night into a felony allegation. Anger doesn't change that, so keep your hands and your mouth to yourself.

Your call

At 19:49 an officer says 'you also spit on me.' What would you need to see to decide whether that shows intent?

Answer in the YouTube comments
Full transcript (183 lines)

Stop.

Stop touching me.

Mom, naw.

Give me my phone back.

Twenty-five minutes of Texas bodycam, one wrecked Dodge Charger, and a legal line

most people think they understand.

A woman says a black truck chased her, and officers have other questions.

Today: one statute, tested against the footage.

Gut check: do handcuffs come out before this ends?

Type Y or N below, and tap like if you've ever lost a fight with a self-checkout.

This is them?

That's the white, that's a white truck, though.

But I'm saying that the other truck that was following me was a black truck.

The black truck. The guys that got into the truck was a black truck.

Okay. So, who are these guys?

I asked them. I was, I was already serving them.

So, who are these people right here?

They're just people that I serve.

And I told them that I was already aware.

And I was already speaking to them.

I've been working there for a few days, like, about a week.

So, what did you...

I've seen them about two days, and I've told them. I told them today.

What'd you hit?

You hit something. What did you hit?

The other car.

What other car?

I don't know. Is it their car?

You hit a car or a tree?

That's the driver's account on scene: a black truck followed her, and she hit

something. Asked what, she says 'the other car,' and the officer asks whether it was

a car or a tree. Keep that exchange in mind.

Next clip, a different argument: her keys and whether her car is running.

Listen for the words 'last opportunity.' It's a push-button start, so even the

dashboard gets a speaking part.

Can I get my keys out of my car?

Not right now, no.

Can I turn my car off?

Yes, I can do that.

Because before I walk away from my car, yes, I can do that.

Okay.

Let's go ahead.

No, I can't get my keys from my vehicle.

Can you go that way?

Can I get my keys from my vehicle?

No.

Can I get my keys from my vehicle?

Yes, you can.

No.

Officer, I know you're allowed to let me get my...

Turn my vehicle off.

Okay.

So, this is the last opportunity.

Okay.

Come over here.

And I also know that it's my last opportunity to get my keys out of my car...

Out of my vehicle.

I'm asking you, officer, can you turn my vehicle off?

Your vehicle is on.

No, it's not.

I'm watching the lights on.

This next beat is serious, so we'll keep it that way.

In the back of a patrol car, she says she can't breathe and that she is

claustrophobic. Listen for what the officers offer her, and for what they decline.

The window's down.

We have AC back here, okay?

I have no-

I can't!

I have a blood disorder!

I can't!

I just need some air, ma'am.

I just need some air.

Medics are coming, okay?

Ma'am, I just-

Just open my window.

I just need some air.

Ma'am, ma'am, the window's open.

I'm pre-

Can you call my mom?

I'm pre-

Can you just let me stand outside?

Ma'am, I'm so claustrophobic.

In just a second.

Medics are coming, okay?

Medics are coming.

They're gonna come and check you out.

Just take deep breaths.

Ma'am!

Can I just stand outside?

Now the rule. Texas Penal Code section 22.11 covers harassment of a public servant.

In plain English: knowingly causing an on-duty public servant, such as an officer,

to contact your saliva, blood, urine or feces, with intent to harass, alarm or

assault, is a third-degree felony.

Three ingredients: contact, a known public servant, and intent.

In the next clip, listen for the sentence where an officer mentions spit.

But you also have a THD and plain view that we saw,

A THD pen, and you also spit on me, okay?

And I, and I understand that.

I understand that you were in a tough spot, okay?

So, I have to read some stuff to you, okay?

Step one: what's actually on the record?

In that clip, an officer tells her, 'you also spit on me, okay?' That's an officer's

statement, not a finding.

The Odessa American, citing a police report in a September 2022 case that appears to

match, says the arresting officer wrote that she spat on her multiple times after

being placed in the patrol car.

Allegations, all of it.

Next, watch how communication works through a closed window.

Your license, permit, approval,

To operate a motor vehicle, be suspended or denied

For not less than one of your days,

Whether or not you are subsequently-

Step two: knowledge and intent.

Courts and prosecutors generally ask whether the person knew they were dealing with

a public servant, whether that officer was on duty, and what the person meant to do.

Intent is rarely on camera.

It gets argued from context, which is why a report, a video and a courtroom can read

the same moment differently.

Next, listen to the warning the officer reads.

The officer may apply for a warrant authorizing

A specimen to be taken from you.

If you are 21 years of age,

If you refuse to give a specimen that-

I need a tissue, Miss Officer Perez,

I'm blowing my nose.

Your license, permit, approval,

To operate a motor vehicle, be suspended or denied

For not less than one of your days,

Whether or not you are subsequently-

I need to blow my nose, and I know you can hear me.

If you refuse to submit-

Taking of a specimen, the officer may apply

For a warrant authorizing the specimen

To be taken from you.

You are 21 years of age or older,

Struggle Ash brings you the footage, the statute, and a straight read on both.

Subscribe, and keep the legal bills for somebody else.

You're under arrest for an offense-

The catch, and the myth.

Myth: cursing at an officer is this felony.

The statute as summarized describes contact with bodily fluid plus intent, and

insults alone aren't what it describes.

Second catch: the DWI side runs separately.

In many states, refusing a breath or blood test can lead to a warrant request and a

license suspension, and the officer here reads a warning saying so.

I don't know what you're talking about.

So, I brought your mom out here, okay?

Takeaway one. Everything said near a camera ends up in a report, so keep requests

short and clear: medical help, a lawyer, whether you're free to go.

Save the argument for a courtroom.

Notice what the officer says here: that he typically doesn't let family talk to

people, but wanted to let that happen.

You're already, you're already under arrest, okay?

I can't, I can't, I, there's, I'm sorry.

Takeaway two. Contact with an officer's body is where a felony allegation of this

kind starts, and intent gets argued later.

Fairness check: officers kept offering medics and air, which is a plus.

A viewer could still question holding her ID and keys, and not letting her stand

outside.

Observations, not verdicts.

Mom ID?

Ma'am, we're past that, okay?

Receipts time. Y people called the handcuffs, N people, brace yourselves.

Like and subscribe, because the next case is already queued.

I understand.

According to the Odessa American, citing an Odessa police report in a September 2022

case that appears to match, the woman was arrested on suspicion of DWI and

harassment of a public servant, a felony punishable by two to ten years.

Those are allegations, not convictions.

No plea, ruling or sentence turned up in our search.

Did you even intoxicate me?

Let me finish this.

Can you intoxicate me?

Can you make, can you, can you go ahead?

Can you go ahead and do that right now?

You will be asked to give a specimen of your breath

And your blood.

All right, go ahead and do that right now.

Allegations only, and no outcome is public.

This felony turns on contact and intent, not insults.

At 19:49 an officer says 'you also spit on me': what proof of intent would you need?

That's the debrief.

Stay out of the struggle.

Related episodes