Struggle Ash Subscribe

Home / Episodes / Volusia Sheriff's Office

EX-017 · Arrests & stops

Deputy vs. 'Private Estate' Car: No License, No ID

A driver pulls over exactly where he wants, a deputy asks for a license, and the answer is a legal theory about a private estate. Let's see how that goes.

Volusia Sheriff's OfficeFloridaVolusia County, FloridaIncident: 11/14/2412:02

Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube

What happened

A Volusia Sheriff's Office deputy stops a driver over a seat belt and a stop sign. The driver says the car belongs to a private estate and that he operates outside the deputy's jurisdiction. He produces no license, and the deputy says he cannot identify him. We pause the footage and break down what happened and the general rules around traffic stops and ID. The outcome is not stated in the source. Footage: Volusia Sheriff's Office bodycam release.

The law in plain English

License and identification

Generally, drivers need a valid license to operate on public roads and must show it on request. During a lawful stop, officers may detain someone while they work out who they are. Courts decide whether a particular stop was lawful.

General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.

Lessons

  1. Stop safely, stay put

    Pull over promptly. The deputy's first words were 'stay in the car.' Following simple instructions early keeps a stop short and calm.

  2. Labels aren't identification

    Officers need something they can verify. In this stop, the deputy said the document wasn't valid identification, and that gap is what the jail warning rested on.

  3. Argue it in court

    The roadside is not the place to litigate. Comply, stay calm, and raise legal challenges later through a lawyer, who can advise on your specific situation.

Your call

At 4:33 the deputy says 'you will be going to jail' if he does not identify himself. Fair warning, or too fast?

Answer in the YouTube comments
Full transcript (151 lines)

"Stay in the car, sir." That's the first thing we hear, and it sets the tone.

A driver pulls over exactly where he wants, a deputy asks for a license, and the

answer is a legal theory about a private estate.

Let's see how that goes.

Stay in the car sir what's going on I'm trying to pull you over I just wanted to

park okay do

You live here I'm in right here yeah okay so usually when you get pulled over you

Stop where you want to stop okay it's very dangerous for us all right so the reason

The stop is two things one you're not wearing your seat belt the second when I was

Behind you you ran the stop sign I didn't run the stop sign you did I put my blinker

on okay

You'd put your blinker on but you didn't stop at the stop sign do you have the

driver's license

Listen to how the deputy explains himself.

First, he says the driver stopped where he wanted, not where the deputy directed.

He says that's dangerous for deputies.

Then he names two reasons for the stop: no seat belt, and a stop sign.

The driver says he put his blinker on.

The deputy answers that a blinker isn't a stop.

Jurisdiction what does that mean this is a private automobile okay it's registered

to a private

Estate okay so you have no form of identification start with this okay

Just do me a favor stay in the car okay not here not a problem do me a favor don't

get out of the

Vehicle please yeah it's motor 44 I'm dealing with a sovereign I'm at a 19 seville

drive if

Now listen for the phrase "private estate." The driver says he operates outside the

deputy's jurisdiction and that the car is registered to an estate.

He has no license, registration or insurance to hand over.

It's a bold opening move...

<chuckle> with the confidence of a man who has not met a stop sign.

The deputy, to his credit, keeps his tone level.

One of you can come over here so you don't have a driver's license sir no so I ran

your tag it's

Not coming back to anything no I need to identify you sir registered to a private

estate

Okay so where is your identification okay can I are you giving me this this is all

private

Property it's not within the jurisdiction of the corporate state of florida okay you

are you you

Work for the corporation am I correct state of florida yeah the corporation

incorporated

All right I have no contract with them no driver's license no registration the car

belongs

Quick bet before we go on: does the driver ever hand over a valid ID?

Y or N below. And tap like if you've ever tried a loophole on a form.

To a private estate okay so private estate trust it's a private estate okay so in

the state of

Florida sir you need a valid driver's license to operate a motor vehicle upon our

streets okay

Also I have no way of identifying you okay you you have a document in your

possession that says

Passport but it is not a passport it is a passport it is not a passport this

passport is

On record with okay with driver's license no I don't have one of those as I'm

telling him it's in

A private estate okay I'm gonna hand this back to you sir so have you ever had a

driver's license

In the state of florida no any other state in the in the country I have none of

those

Haven't had one don't use them okay what's your first name you can call me anthony

is that your

Your government name or that is what with that is my given okay sir so here's what's

going to end up

Watch the document exchange.

The deputy says a document the driver holds says passport, but he says it is not a

passport. He says he has no way of identifying the driver.

The deputy asks if he has ever held a license, and the driver says no.

The deputy asks for a first name, and gets the answer: you can call me Anthony.

Happening okay if you do not identify yourself you will be going to jail I and I

would hate to

Do that you my identification that's not a valid identification and when you say to

florida driver's

License to drive it's that simple no you don't have a driver's license you can go to

jail that's

What's going to happen today I'm trying to be respectful I am too a license is not I

already

Told you what's going to happen

That's where we're at we're not playing the game today this isn't even that's not a

passport no

It's not all right traveling upon and transporting one driver's license traveling

upon and transporting

One's property upon public roads which is a right hold on before before this let's

go ahead and step

Out of the vehicle step out of the vehicle all right all right I'm coming out then

Here's a decision a reasonable viewer might admire: the deputy lays out the

consequence before acting.

He says if the driver does not identify himself, he will be going to jail, and that

he would hate to do that.

That's a clear warning.

A question some might raise: the order to exit comes right as the driver starts

talking about traveling on public roads.

Your head don't resist you you got my stop tensing stop tensing stop right now put

Hands behind your back and stop tensing you got my car I'll leave it here that's

fine

Just one second I'll talk to you after this is all done and said with here

If you have anything on your person that's going to poke me stick me hurt me no

Separate your feet in the background

Front seat separate your feet separate your feet sir all you had to do was identify

yourself that's

Identification then I already called 10 15. okay all I require is the passport with

Would you get just given my wallet and my lighter and change or can you just put it

back in the car

Unless you want him to have it I can give it to him

Struggle Ash is where we pause real bodycam at the moment it counts.

Subscribe, and learn the rules from your couch instead of the roadside.

Yeah that's 10-4 we have a 10-15 and he failed to identify himself

My passport I need my passport with me

It's lawful id I think someone said they were on their way to us I think someone

said they were on

Our the way to us have a seat sir sovereign citizen games don't play here I'm not a

sovereign

General information, not advice for this case.

In many states, drivers must carry a license and show it when stopped, and officers

can generally detain someone to identify them during a lawful stop.

Florida law is cited by the deputy: a valid license is needed to drive on public

streets. Whether the stop and the arrest hold up is for a court.

Vehicle please yeah it's motor 44 I'm dealing with a sovereign I'm at a 19 seville

drive if

Lesson one. Where you stop matters.

The deputy says pulling over where you want, not where the officer directs, is

dangerous for them.

Stop promptly and safely, then keep your hands visible and stay put.

Florida sir you need a valid driver's license to operate a motor vehicle upon our

streets okay

Lesson two. A label doesn't make a document official.

The deputy says the item is not a passport and he cannot identify the driver from

it. An ID the officer can verify ends the question in seconds.

One's property upon public roads which is a right hold on before before this let's

go ahead and step

Lesson three. Legal theories belong in a courtroom, not the roadside.

The driver argues rights while the deputy repeats one simple thing: he needs a

license to drive. Arguments about jurisdiction are made later, to a judge.

Yeah that's 10-4 we have a 10-15 and he failed to identify himself

My passport I need my passport with me

Remember your Y or N?

Hold that thought while we check what the source says.

Like if you called it, and subscribe for the next case.

Our the way to us have a seat sir sovereign citizen games don't play here I'm not a

sovereign

Citizen oh you need a license to drive

As for the outcome: the footage ends with the driver seated while the deputy says he

needs a license to drive.

The deputy radios a 10-15 and says the man failed to identify himself.

Charges and any court result are not public in the source.

The takeaway: a verifiable ID would have ended this stop faster than any legal

theory.

Final question: when the deputy gave the jail warning at 4:33, was that fair notice,

or the point where he should have slowed down?

That's the debrief.

Stay out of the struggle.

Related episodes