Struggle Ash Subscribe

Home / Episodes / Utah Department of Public Safety

EX-028 · Arrests & stops

Utah Trooper Spots a Suspect Van, Then Waits. Why?

He spots it, and he does not hit the lights. Why does he wait?

Utah Department of Public SafetyUtahI-15 near Parowan, UtahIncident: August 1, 201910:22

Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube

What happened

On August 1, 2019, a Utah Highway Patrol trooper near Parowan recognized a white minivan's driver from FBI-provided suspect photos in an out-of-state child-abduction case. We break down three decision points in the Exit 78 stop, from the wait to the walk-back commands, plus the stop-versus-arrest standards behind them. Charges are alleged, and no later court outcome was found. Footage: official body camera release from the Utah Department of Public Safety (dpsnews.utah.gov). Statute reference: Utah Code 76-5-302, general information only.

The law in plain English

Utah Code 76-5-302 (aggravated kidnapping)

Kidnapping becomes aggravated when done with a weapon or with intent such as holding a victim, terrorizing them, or injuring them. It is a first-degree felony. Not confirmed as a charge here.

General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.

Lessons

  1. Report before you act

    Calling out the vehicle, driver and seating early lets backup arrive informed. When officers hang back, information-gathering is often part of the reason.

  2. Comply now, contest later

    Roadside is not the place to argue. Visible hands and following commands shorten the stop. Disputes are handled later, with a lawyer and a judge.

  3. Tell them about the kids

    Officers commonly control the scene first, then move children to safety. Calm, quick answers about who is in the vehicle help that happen faster.

Your call

Which moment decided this stop: the wait, the off-ramp choice, or the walk-back commands?

Answer in the YouTube comments
Full transcript (105 lines)

One trooper. One white minivan.

Five people inside, two of them very young children.

He spots it, and he does not hit the lights.

Why does he wait?

Have that subject 82 southbound it's gonna be the California 1028 7 Zulu Mike

Uniform 960 it's gonna be a white Dodge Caravan I'll wait till I have some 1078

Then I'll go 1060

August first, 2019, Interstate 15 near Parowan.

According to the Department of Public Safety, a Highway Patrol trooper sees a white

minivan pass and recognizes the driver from suspect photos provided by the FBI.

Then he calls out the driver and the seating chart over the radio, like a sports

announcer on a very quiet game.

<chuckle> Agencies commonly train this, so backup knows the layout before anyone

moves.

Just 1014 the mark subjects driving and then the other individuals in the back

Left

Quick bet. Does this stop end peacefully?

Y or N in the comments.

And leave a like if you would have waited for backup.

I'm just coming up to 78 I'm gonna wait till I have somebody to attempt stop

With three of them and possibly 1088 I'm gonna wait

Three moments decided this stop.

Moment three: the wait.

He counts three people in the van and says it plainly, he's going to wait.

The fork was lights on the highway, or patience.

Waiting costs distance.

It also buys a better place to stop.

Forward is coming on 78 he's gonna take exit 78 I'm gonna attempt to stop on the

Moment two: where. The van takes Exit 78, and the trooper says he will attempt the

stop on the off ramp.

According to the Department of Public Safety, he judged a stop there was needed to

keep the public from harm at a nearby gas station.

The other option was letting it roll into a parking lot.

Nobody at that pump signed up to be an extra.

Your hands keep walking back turn around follow back come back keep coming back

Keep coming back put your hands on the dash on my car put your hands on your

Back have a seat on the ground

You gotta help me up okay sit down go down I got you okay just lay right there

Passenger I understand left seat open up I got that let me see your hands come

Moment one, the most decisive.

He does not walk up to the van.

He calls people to him.

Come back, hands visible, hands on the car, sit on the ground.

Agencies commonly train this, because someone moving away from a vehicle with

visible hands has less chance to reach into it.

The alternative is one trooper alone at a window.

And yes, it looks like a very serious moonwalk.

Out of the car or be quiet let me see your hands turn around backwards I got

Him let me call him back walk backwards slowly yeah keep going walking back

Stop right there take to the right step to the right okay go for it

Struggle Ash brings you real bodycam, paused where the choice gets made.

Subscribe, it's free, and nobody makes you walk backwards.

Cedar 385 we have Mark 1082 just calling out the others right now not yet

Be quiet we got the female still with the babies are we get that Cedar 385 1082 with

the second male

Backup arrives, according to DPS: a Parowan police officer, a second trooper and an

Iron County deputy.

The radio call is plain.

The woman is still in the van with the babies.

A fair question is whether starting this alone was the right call.

ABC4 reports the stop ended without incident.

Way to call the link give the lady out what's her name Angela let us seeing her

Hands thank I'm go I'm approaching we getOWNapproachin' we get that we get

That EPI can we see the let me see the baby go to that officer right over there

Hey ma'am ma'am go to that officer right there right now

Officers can stop a vehicle on reasonable suspicion.

An arrest needs probable cause.

When a suspect may be dangerous, agencies commonly use a high-risk stop:

distance, commands, hands visible.

Utah's aggravated kidnapping statute,

76-5-302, is a first-degree felony.

No record here confirms that charge.

We're just passing 81 now it's gonna be the marks subject is driving

Do this instead, lesson one.

Information first, action second.

The trooper reports the van, the driver and the seats before he tries to stop

anything. Agencies commonly train that, because backup that knows the layout moves

safer.

Lesson two. If an officer orders you out, comply and contest it later.

On the roadside, visible hands and walking where you are told is the fastest way to

end a stop. Arguments belong in a courtroom.

General information, not legal advice.

Southbound off ramp

Lesson three. If children are in a vehicle, say so early and calmly.

Officers commonly secure the adults first, then move the children to safety, so

quick answers shorten the wait.

1060 78 southbound off ramp

Y meant a calm stop, N meant it escalated.

Hold your answer. The ending is next, and a subscribe gets you tomorrow's case.

Go to him right now hi hi how are you go to that officer right over there right

Now go to him right now okay

Now the ending. According to ABC4, three adults were arrested without incident, and

the two young children were found safe.

St. George News reports two men and a woman were booked into Iron County Jail,

described as facing possible felony kidnapping charges.

DPS released the footage in mid-August 2019.

No later plea, trial or sentence was found.

Remember why he waited?

He waited for the off ramp, a spot he judged safer for the public.

Let Dispatch know we're 82 with the female.

Hi, how are you?

Calm radio, a patient stop, clear commands.

Which moment decided it: the wait, the off ramp, or the walk back?

That's the debrief.

Stay out of the struggle.

Related episodes