Struggle Ash Subscribe

Home / Episodes / Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources

EX-013 · Game wardens

Deacon's Plate Number Cracked a 238-Violation Deer Case

How do you catch someone this quiet?

Virginia Department of Wildlife ResourcesVirginiaSouthwest VirginiaIncident: Summer 202312:37

Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube

What happened

Over the summer of 2023, Virginia conservation police officers worked a string of night-time deer killings across Southwest Virginia: no gunshots heard, no vehicle description, and nothing taken from the animals. Senior Conservation Police Officer Derrick Rickels walks through how community tips, a church deacon's plate number, and cooperation between agencies led to an arrest and prosecution. We break down the spotlighting method, the investigation's decision points, and what the legal terms mean in plain English. If you see wildlife violations, report them to the Virginia DWR link in the original description. Credit: Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources, True Wildlife Crime podcast. Footage and interview used from the official DWR release.

The law in plain English

Taken under advisement

Some charges are held on file instead of being decided. In this case, Rickels says that lasted 12 months on supervised probation. If another violation occurs, he says the held charges can come back before the judge. General information, not legal advice.

General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.

Lessons

  1. Call it in

    Officers can't work what they don't know about. Note dates, locations and vehicle details, report through official channels such as the DWR link, and don't confront anyone yourself.

  2. Phones keep records

    Rickels says texts and location data helped tie statements to reported dates. Violations can stack: out of season, at night, with a spotlight, near homes.

Your call

Which was the bigger break: the deacon's plate number, or the off-duty investigator waiting near the lit-up field?

Answer in the YouTube comments
Full transcript (232 lines)

They're stunned so they just stand they woke up one morning and there were just six

deer dead in

Dozens of deer shot overnight, in the middle of summer.

No gunshots heard. No vehicle.

No witnesses. Southwest Virginia wildlife officers needed one clue, and it showed up

in an unlikely place.

How do you catch someone this quiet?

When was the first call that we got okay so the first call we got was on june 10th

We got a report of one deer found shot gunshots were heard no other information was

given no

Vehicle description or anything like that so just one shot was there there was a

Okay but nothing no no other information that was literally all they could give us

all right so in

Prediction time: do the officers catch them?

Comment Y for yes, N for no.

And smash that like if you've ever slept through something you absolutely should

have heard.

So they woke up one morning and there were just six deer dead in their front yard

yeah so they

Have a hayfield their house sits on one side of the road the hayfield's on the other

And as soon as they came out the deer were within a couple hundred yards of their

house that's gonna

Be a little disturbing right this this area of the county has a high deer population

so seeing

Deer isn't uncommon in that area but to see that many dead in that one location was

June 19th. Six deer dead in a hayfield across from a house.

Rickels says officers found more along the road nearby, all appearing shot from it.

That's a lot of deer, one night, and no calls.

Now listen for what's missing: the part where anybody took anything.

Velvet um so sometimes we'll see people shooting

Bucks at that time of the year to try to get one in velvet that's kind of rare

Or if they're not going to take any antlers at least they're going to take some meat

None of these deer that we found were touched anyway so middle of the summer

obviously out of

Season right and didn't take anything right and it at this time in the summer it's

anywhere from

Here's the method, per Rickels.

Shine a light in a deer's eyes and it freezes.

As it turned out, one person held the light while another shot.

Officers also suspected a suppressor, since nobody heard shots.

Suppressors are legal for hunting in season, he notes.

Summer nights? Different story.

Listen to how he describes the deer's reaction.

It do to the deer right so anytime a light is shown in a deer's eyes just think

If you walk into a bright room in the middle of the night then you turn around and

walk back you

Can't see anything right your night vision's kind of gone with a deer it's kind of

compounded so

When a lot gets shown in their eyes they're stunned they don't know where it's

coming from

They don't know their methods of escape so they just stand just stand there just

shooting fish

In a barrel

Pretty much yeah they're most of the time they're not going to be moving at all

Like I said because they don't know where they need to go to get away from it

Meanwhile, the staffing puzzle.

Rickels says two counties had no assigned officer, and summer meant river patrols.

So: boats or night patrols?

A fair debate, and he lays out the tradeoff.

They tried saturation patrols across counties.

Listen for how well that went.

Point you'd probably have just as much success throwing a dart at a dartboard and

that's kind of

What we had to do we did saturation patrols with multiple officers in the same area

we did one

Officer on one of the county one officer on the north end just nothing was working

for us we

Didn't know where they were going to be when they were going to be it was weekdays

and weekends some

Of them we believe were shot closer to three to four o'clock in the morning some of

July 26th. Three more deer on Stoney Creek Road, the first time the shooters return

to the same spot. Cameras catch a truck and trailer.

Rickels' problem? In Southwest Virginia, that description fits plenty of driveways.

Also, per Rickels, people there sleep hard.

Listen for his description.

Went back to the same place we did finally get a vehicle description through some

cameras that were

In the area of a newer model black chevy or gmc truck that was pulling a trailer

with a utv on it

So finally we were kind of whittling everything down all the information we've

gathered we're

Trying to develop a suspect try to develop an area where we need to work to

hopefully apprehend them

August 12th. Two deer on Golf Course Road, right by the Gate City limits, within a

short drive of three departments.

Rickels says one was killed within 200 yards of a house.

This is where a wildlife case becomes a public safety one.

Notice how he explains the angle.

Enforcement that they're doing this right in town so so the ego has expanded and

that they feel like

They can take a few more risks right and these these two deer one of them was act it

was probably

The biggest buck that we know of that they harvested um were killed within 200 yards

of a uh

Of a house right in this guy's front yard the only area they could have shot it from

would have put

The house as the backstop so when you fire a weapon we want you to be safe know

what's your

Then a church enters the story.

Rickels says officers checked church video, but no tag number was visible on the

truck. Then the deacon calls him directly, on a day he was about to start parental

leave. Not a deputy, not a detective.

Listen for what the deacon's buddy has.

Visible or any other identifying features on the truck to narrow it down I was I had

a baby back in

April and was about to start my second month of parental leave and my wife went back

to work

To mark off duty for the last time before I was off for that month uh that deacon

called me oh man

Said hey my buddy just got behind that truck and I've got a plate number for you so

that that's

Rickels says he had dispatch run the tag, and the team dug into social media.

Then came a gap: officers didn't know where the owner had been hunting, because, per

Rickels, he had no license and no harvest data in several years.

Listen for how he explains it.

Them now he didn't have any harvest data so did he have a license at all or he just

hadn't no license

No harvest data in the last several years all right which in virginia you've got a

People that are licensed exempt

The 26th. An off-duty Scott County sheriff's investigator spots the matching truck

and waits. Rickels says he saw a field lit up, then found the truck with nobody

around it. He recognized the personalized tag.

Watch how the scene builds, and how officers gather.

Of what these uh suspects mo were on the 26th a an off-duty scott county sheriff's

office

Investigator was going back to his house saw a vehicle matching that description

just kind of

Sat there and waited just to see if he may get lucky enough to see these people

spotlight

They drove past about 30 seconds later he saw

A vehicle and he saw a vehicle that was in the way of the field uh being illuminated

the only

Way that field could get bright with light would be if somebody was shining that

with a spotlight

One thing officers did well: the investigator called a neighboring landowner to

check nobody had permission there.

Then a truck arrives with three people: an older man, a juvenile and a younger

adult. Rickels says the owner was one of the passengers.

Listen for the explanation he describes.

A truck came down the road with three occupants an older man a juvenile and a

younger adult

At that point like I said we knew who the suspect was that owned the truck and were

able to identify

Him as one of the passengers he tried to make the excuse that he believed that he

had hit a deer but

The officers didn't see any damage on the vehicle or anything like that I think when

you hit a deer

You know you hit something and there's very rarely is there not any evidence right

like fur tops

Per Rickels, officers saw no damage on the truck.

A remarkably deer-free vehicle for a deer collision.

In interviews, he says the adult admitted shining and shooting at a deer, and the

juvenile said he held the light.

A suppressed rifle and spotlight were found at a grandfather's house.

Then came the phone.

Interview he showed the officers pictures on his phone of other animals that we that

he had killed

We had no idea about he had shot two bears during the summertime which is obviously

not it's during

The closed season as well as well as a federally protected owl so at that point we

seized the phone

Absolutely because there's evidence of different crimes or the crimes that they've

been committing

As well as ones we didn't know about we seized those fun or his phone um the rifle

Um so we took a look at the keys that they might have been marking or whatever

Phone at the point we did that that we took a look at the case and we ended up and

Bunch of pictures, took written statements. And from that point, they kind of went

back and now

Rickels says officers believed about 55 deer were killed, and 33 could be tied to

statements, text messages and location data.

Asked why, he says the statement was that they just wanted to kill things.

Listen for how the messages lined up with reported dates.

Something that the adult was just taking them along, they made them go with them.

And it was

Quite the opposite. It was a lot of, Hey, do you want to go out tonight? Let's see

how many we can

Kill tonight. And we were able to tie those conversations with the calls for service

We had gotten over the last several months. So there were several dates that we had

deer reported

That lined up exactly to their text messages. So that made a lot of the case for us

because we can

Gather evidence and we can gather statements, but unless we can tie the two

together,

Struggle Ash: we pause the footage so you don't learn the hard way.

Subscribe. It's free, and so is the advice.

Somebody that's not informed may believe that, well, that's just a hunter that went

out there

And did that. That's not a hunter in my eyes and I don't think in the eyes of our

department. That's

A violator. That's all they wanted to do was go out there and violate the law.

Two concepts, general info only.

First, seasons and hours.

Rickels says suppressors are legal for hunting in Virginia in a normal season, with

federal registration.

But out of season, at night, with a light?

In his words, everything else has gone out the window.

Second, charges can be taken under advisement.

We really depend on our public and our other law enforcement partners. They may be

in an area where

We can't drive by for two weeks. And if we don't know that there's a problem, we

can't work it.

Lesson one: reports matter.

Rickels says officers can't work a problem they don't know about.

Dates, locations and a vehicle description help, and agencies share information,

even across state lines.

Report violations through official channels, and don't confront anyone.

To line on our end of the state they may have something on their end we work cases

in the past

Where we've had a group coming from virginia making a loop into tennessee killing

deer over

There and in virginia and we work hand in hand with them to collect evidence to make

Lesson two: phones keep records.

Rickels says text messages and location data tied statements to reported dates.

Violations also stack: out of season, at night, with a light, near homes.

Every added line crossed adds another thing to sort through.

And obviously, the CPOs with the department worked for months to wrap this up. But

every

Major break came from somebody calling us, somebody telling us, letting us know that

Alright, Y people and N people, here's how it went.

If you liked this case, smash like and subscribe for the next one.

Required to pay $3,800 in restitution to landowners. That's something I was glad to

See these people were having to take time out of their day, use their equipment,

their fuel

With the cost of everything. Now, I felt like that was kind of given back to the

community

That helped us make this case. There was 10,000, a little over $10,000 in

replacement costs for the

Per Officer Rickels in the DWR podcast, the adult's plea left seven Class 1

misdemeanors finalized, 91 charges held for 12 months, and $3,800 restitution.

Takeaway: tips and teamwork beat quiet shooters.

Which was the bigger break: the deacon's plate number, or the investigator's

patience by that lit-up field?

Related episodes