Struggle Ash Subscribe

Home / Episodes / Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources

EX-003 · Game wardens

Wildlife Agent, a Facebook Post & a Head in a Flower Pot

How do you get from a single photo to a deer head in a flower pot?

Virginia Department of Wildlife ResourcesVirginiaRichmond, Virginia11:55

Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube

What happened

A famously photographed buck lived in Richmond's cemeteries. Then one Facebook post started a wildlife investigation. Virginia DWR Special Agent Zach Howlett walks through the first 24 hours: the tips, the carcasses behind a house, a long interview, a car that ran out of gas, and a deer head wrapped in a trash bag inside a flower pot. We pause his account, explain the check-in and search-warrant basics, and cover what the agency says happened in court. Footage and interview: Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources, 'True Wildlife Crime' episode 2. Report wildlife violations: https://dwr.virginia.gov/conservation-police/wildlife-violation/

The law in plain English

License vs. check-in

A hunting license lets you hunt. A deer check-in records the animal you took. Officers can search check records by name, and a missing or inaccurate record can be its own violation. Vehicle searches generally need a warrant, and preservation orders ask carriers to keep phone records.

General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.

Lessons

  1. A post is a timestamped lead

    Howlett says the key evidence came within 24 hours of the post. Online photos, tips and recent pictures from other people can build a timeline fast.

  2. Cameras and agencies add up

    Howlett describes doorbell video, security footage, phone-record preservation, and help from several agencies. Together they pieced together a timeline of where two men went that night.

  3. If you see something, say something

    Howlett lists a hotline, tip line, email and app. Email wildcrime@dwr.virginia.gov or call 1-800-237-5712. You can also report online at dwr.virginia.gov.

Your call

Howlett left the suspect a voicemail the first night instead of waiting for a face-to-face. Smart move or a gamble?

Answer in the YouTube comments
Full transcript (210 lines)

Road and about 10 minutes later he comes back uh with the deer head in his vehicle

uh wrapped up in

A buck lived in Richmond's cemeteries for years.

Then one Facebook post set off a wildlife investigation.

How do you get from a single photo to a deer head in a flower pot?

Richmond area, well photographed throughout the area as well. We had wildlife

photographers that

Would come take pictures of it. It was well known throughout the hunting community

as a very notable

Buck. It had been living in the cemeteries there for quite some time. Based off of

the teeth that

Were pulled from the deer on the jawbone, a biologist recommended or suggested that

the age

Was going to be somewhere between eight and nine years old. Wow, so been living in

that community

Prediction time: do investigators get all three sets of antlers back?

Comment Y for yes, N for no, and smash like if you've ever regretted a social media

post.

With the post on Star City Whitetails,

That occurred on the 14th of December. I was notified that day by another officer

that was

Working as well as an employee within the agency. They sent me a text message with

the post from

Star City and that's when the investigation began. I believe we first made a call

for service around

3.30 that afternoon and that's when, like I said, the investigation really took

place.

So here's the clock.

Special Agent Howlett says the post went up December 14th, another officer texted it

to him that day, and the first call for service came around 3:30 that afternoon.

A Facebook page full of deer people turns out to be a tough room.

Listen for how many tips he says came in within the first couple of hours.

No. So like I said, I was first notified by a CPO, but probably within the first

hour to two hours,

We had over a dozen tips come in from individuals on Star City, like followers of

the page,

As well as just, like I said, people that saw it circulating online. So individuals

that did see the

Post on Star City's Facebook page, those people did call in and gave us tips about

the individual,

Over a dozen tips in a couple of hours, from followers of the page and people who

saw the post circulating.

That's the community doing legwork.

Meanwhile, Howlett says the first step was paperwork: licenses and check-in records.

Watch for what he says he could not find for the buck.

We really didn't know much about the individual. So just the preliminary

investigation was

Obviously try to look up who this guy is. We try to make sure he's got all the

proper licenses,

Where he's living at. What we were able to find right off the get-go was

That the buck was not checked in at all. There was no record of it being checked in.

He did have all the proper licenses to hunt during that timeframe.

But as far as any check records coming in, we weren't able to find anything for that

Quick vocab: a license lets you hunt, while a check-in records the deer you actually

took. Howlett says the man had the proper licenses but no check record for this

buck, and that he claimed it was killed in Prince Edward County or Richmond.

A famous city deer taking a day trip to the countryside?

Howlett's word: very unlikely.

We were also able to locate that same day, three deer carcasses behind the residence

Where he lived at, all in different stages of decay, which kind of matched with the

timeline

That the pictures were posted on Star City. So that kind of all lined up to where

you've got

One that's in the most decay, one that's kind of in the middle. And then the last

deer that we

Found was in a creek bottom behind the house. And that was one that had just been

decayed.

Decapitated, still had the hide on. No meat had been removed, essentially just

dumped in the

Three carcasses, three stages of decay, one dumped in a creek with the hide still

on. Howlett says all three were on Richmond Public School property behind the

suspect's house. Credit where due: they got that far the same day.

One problem: no head, no antlers.

So how do you ID a headless deer?

Watch the front knees.

With the suspect posing with it in the backyard. There was some characteristics near

the knees,

Front knees of the deer, where there was specific wear marks in the fur.

That deer that was laying in the creek had that same exact matching characteristics

on its front

Matching worn fur on the front knees to a photo is how you link a headless animal to

a post. Then comes a judgment call.

Howlett says he left the man a voicemail that night about a Facebook post.

A viewer could ask if that tips someone off.

The next day, Howlett says, the man called back.

Listen for 'muzzleloader.'

He was forthcoming on some stuff right from the get-go he did admit that the deer

wasn't

Shot in prince edward right from the get-go he admit that he didn't shoot it with

the muzzle

Loader like the post originally stated uh he said he shot it with a crossbow from

there he kind of

Led me on a path of a story that I just kept feeding them line to let him kind of

see where

He wanted to end up with it um we had to backtrack a lot during the interview

because there were a lot

Howlett says the interview ran about three hours, and the man didn't know officers

already knew about the carcasses.

Investigators often let someone commit to a story before checking it against

evidence. Then the head: the man wouldn't say where it was, so the deal was officers

wait at the end of the street.

Watch what happens fifty yards from the house.

Spoiler: the fuel gauge.

He gets out of the vehicle and his car ran out of gas

So we said well if we can get it to the closest gas station at the end of the street

we'll put

We'll put some gas money in your car and we'll continue on how kind of you after

that we drive

About 20 minutes down the road um we stop at a restaurant uh off of route I believe

it was

Route 360 or route one I can't remember the street name uh we stopped there he

drives down a dead end

Officers fronting gas money so a suspect can fetch the evidence: peak customer

service. Howlett says about ten minutes down a dead-end road later, the man returned

with the head in a trash bag in a flower pot.

A viewer might question letting him out of sight.

Next day, officers walk that dead-end street, where Howlett describes a dark SUV and

a knock and talk.

Vehicle obviously had been cleaned a little bit but we were able to find still a lot

of deer hair

Blood on pretty much every panel within the vehicle there was evidence of archery

equipment

Shotgun shells 22 shell casings pretty much any type of firearm there was evidence

that it had

Been used in that vehicle but the big like I said the big giveaway was there was

A search warrant is a judge-approved permission slip to search a specific place,

here the SUV. Howlett lists deer hair, blood on pretty much every panel, archery

gear, shotgun shells and .22 casings.

Then the video evidence.

Watch for the truck breaking down right in front of a security camera.

That's two vehicle problems in one case.

His truck coincidentally actually breaks down

On the side of the road,

Right in front of a security camera.

So he's run out of gas and now he's broken down.

Right, not the best luck with vehicles.

No.

Both suspects are seen outside of the vehicle

For around 40 minutes to an hour trying to get it fixed.

Then they both walk off from the camera footage.

And then not too long later,

You do see the actual black SUV come back into play

Where it passes the vehicle

That's broke down the suspect's vehicle.

It's about, goes off camera for six minutes

You're watching Struggle Ash, where we break down real enforcement cases so you know

what not to do. Subscribe - it's free, unlike a hunting license.

Like 10 o'clock I called him up and I said hey do you have a deer head with this

suspect's name

Pretty sure I do can we meet you I know it's late but we need to get this head in

our possession so

We were able to drive to his shop that night around 10 o'clock and get that other

set second

What the law says. A hunting license and a deer check-in are two different things.

Howlett says investigators searched check records by name, and the taxidermist had

been given a check number.

Separately, officers generally seek a search warrant to search a vehicle, and

preservation orders ask phone companies to keep records.

Wow. So you guys were on it.

Right. Something like this, you definitely have to kind of, it's hot on the

Grass, we kind of like to say, you've got to get it while the fire is hot.

Because as an officer, I know the longer we go without having that head back in our

possession,

Lesson one: speed. Howlett says you've got to get it while the fire is hot, and that

the main evidence came within about 24 hours of the post.

A trophy photo online is also a timestamped lead.

Resources that played a role in this we had to reach out to a lot of the local

localities and

Some state agencies so we had new kent county sheriff's office also helped in the

case city

Of richmond police department enrico police department chesterfield county pd we

also had

Some work done that the atf actually helped out in some of the case as well on some

of the

Lesson two: it's rarely one agency.

Howlett names a sheriff's office, several police departments, ATF for phone data and

a park system. Add doorbell and restaurant cameras.

'Nobody was watching' is a weak plan in a city full of cameras.

What can they do so we have several methods they can either call in uh to our

hotline and report it

Or we have a tip line they can either do that um we have email they can email in

their tip and even

On our app that we have you can report in a tip on our app as well there's no way

you can't reach

Us correct so email phone text app we're here we want to hear from you if you see

something out

Lesson three: if something in the woods looks off, report it.

The tip line, email and app Howlett mentions are all ways to do it.

In this case, the community's tips are the reason it moved so fast.

The case that that were involved in it uh this was their first big wildlife crime

that they have

Ever worked and they did an outstanding job as far as reaching out to us uh letting

us uh providing

Us anything that we needed for the case

Uh they were a huge help with that and they were willing like I said to work with

really with

Alright, Y people and N people, here's how it went.

Like and subscribe for the next case, because nobody wants to miss a flower pot.

The the final penalties so the final penalties for the main suspect he pled guilty

to all all 20

Charges um the big thing that we were able to get was

The replacement cost on all three deer which totaled around eleven thousand dollars

Replacement cost for the deer and then we were also able to suspend his hunting

privileges

For a hundred years we suspended 76 of those so it was an active 24 years

According to Virginia DWR Special Agent Howlett, the main suspect pleaded guilty to

all 20 charges, and investigators got all three sets of antlers back.

Takeaway: a trophy photo can become a case file.

Was that first-night voicemail smart, or a gamble?

Tell us below.

Related episodes