EX-010 · Game wardens
Wildlife Officers Spot Phone Stashed Under Store Display
Can a man with a history on the shore stay one step ahead?
Virginia Department of Wildlife ResourcesVirginiaVirginia's Eastern ShoreIncident: 201610:27
Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube
What happened
A landowner calls a Virginia conservation police officer about a truck on the railroad tracks. What follows involves two unplugged shotguns, a baited pond, a Christmas-shopping alibi and a phone under a store display. Officer Brian Bratton walks through the 2016 Eastern Shore case in his own words, and we break down the procedures and rules behind it. This is general information, not legal advice. Source: Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources, True Wildlife Crime podcast. The program says it reflects the officer's personal account and is not an official statement of the department.
The law in plain English
Plugs, bait and permission
Waterfowl shotguns must be plugged to hold no more than three shells, per Bratton. Baiting means placing feed to lure birds; hunting over bait is a federal violation. Hunting posted private land without permission is trespass. Revoked privileges mean hunting is its own charge.
General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.
Lessons
Check your plug first
Waterfowl shotguns must hold no more than three shells. Bratton says both guns here held five. A quick check at the truck beats a federal wildlife charge.
Permission and phone calls
Only hunt private land with the owner's permission. Bratton says this case began with a landowner's phone call. If you see a possible violation, report it.
Your call
Officers waited a few days before asking for the main suspect's phone. Smart patience, or did it hand him a head start?
Answer in the YouTube commentsFull transcript (186 lines)
Over, turns it over and reaches underneath it and pulls, pulls out something that
we're looking through binoculars.
One phone call from a landowner.
Two officers, two loaded shotguns, a muddy man walking the railroad tracks, and a
phone stashed under a store display.
Can a man with a history on the shore stay one step ahead?
Team but it all started with exactly what you said um someone from the community a
landowner
Who I'd met previously um you kind of formed a relation with the relationship with
um he has a
Piece of property up there and what these what this piece of property is there's
several old
Fisher rearing ponds on this where they used to raise fish well one afternoon he saw
somebody
Prediction time: do the officers collect enough evidence to bring charges?
Comment Y for yes, N for no.
And smash like if you've ever hidden something badly.
Of town for the afternoon I was literally loading up my truck getting ready to leave
when this guy
Called but he called me and told me that he located a truck that's parked on the
railroad
Tracks they were driven onto the railroad tracks driven down the tracks and trying
to hide their
Trucks among the bushes and then crossed the creek and went over to the other side
Road onto his property then he started telling me who the truck belonged to and as
you said this
Here's the setup, per Officer Bratton.
A landowner sees someone on his property and calls Bratton's phone directly.
Small community, everybody knows everybody.
Bratton says he was loading his truck to leave town when the call came, so the plans
changed. Next clip: watch for what the federal officer sees on the road.
Away from the location I told him what I had said hey head there you'll see what
You can find I'm on my way so about 10 minutes later as he's approaching the
Location he's about a mile away from where this suspects car is parked at he
Passes a gray
Sedan you know coming past him leap leaving the property and he sees in the
Passenger seat of that he sees a subject in green camouflage that he
Bratton was 35 to 40 minutes away, so he called US Fish and Wildlife Officer Darren
Dick, who was about 10 to 15 minutes out.
Fair credit: they used the closest badge.
Dick passes a gray sedan, then meets a man soaking wet and covered in mud.
Bratton says he looked like he'd had an adventure.
That man says it's his buddy's truck.
Yes yes yeah yeah he had it in some brush or something to that effect he made he
made a
Mild effort to hide it not a not a great effort but he he did try to stash some of
their gear but
Um you know he he was very forthcoming with us and he took us back there showed it
where it was
Um we went back there that's where we found two shotguns both of them were unplugged
loaded with
Two shotguns, both unplugged, five shells each, per Bratton.
That's ten shells and zero plugs.
Bratton says the man was forthcoming and walked them to the gear.
He made a mild effort to hide it, Bratton says, not a great one.
Next, the man's account of the day.
Listen for the word baited.
He come out we walked back there you found the shotguns there were three wood ducks
With them as well continued talking to him we sat down basically told him tell us
Happened today start start from the beginning and turns out that earlier that
morning they
Had both met up the road and we're going to go hunt a pond and they went up into
maryland and
Per the second man's account, as Bratton relays it: they hunted a Maryland pond that
Bratton says had been baited.
Then they came back to Virginia, shot three geese, and dropped them at the main
suspect's house.
Officers couldn't leave a truck sitting on a railroad track, so they towed it.
A practical call. Next: watch for the trail into the marsh.
We walk over there, look at the tree.
Obviously, there's no geese there, but you could see fresh blood on the ground where
they had been there earlier.
So as we're walking around to the house to,
You know, walk around to try and knock on a side door or something,
We notice a very prominent trail leading off into the marsh.
You know, we walk down that trail, you know, through the marsh and
Ride around there, you come to a little opening with a tree in the middle of it.
At the end of a trail through the marsh, per Bratton: three freshly killed geese and
three deer skulls being dried out.
Then a phone call. The main suspect denied everything and said he was in Maryland
Christmas shopping.
Bratton says it was November, and that's why he had trouble believing it.
A Christmas alibi, delivered in November.
Listen for Bratton's reasoning.
I was up in Maryland Christmas shopping.
Oh, wow.
Fully out of state.
Nowhere, nowhere nearby.
Yeah.
And left his poor friend out, hanging out to dry.
Obviously the other, the main reason that I had trouble believing that statement is,
uh, this was November.
And as a guy myself, I know that no, no guy starts Christmas shopping in November.
Unless he's dragged along by his wife.
Exactly.
You know, it was out of duress.
Exactly.
A few days later the main suspect agrees to meet officers in a store parking lot.
Bratton says his pants looked empty, as if he'd left his phone behind, though they'd
just spoken to him.
A reasonable viewer could ask whether the days between contacts gave anyone time to
prepare. Bratton says people learn.
Watch the officers wait in the shadows.
Um, we noticed that he's wearing, um, you know, baggy pants and it, you could tell,
it looks like there's not any weight in the pockets.
You know, it looks like he purposefully didn't bring his cell phone with him, which
we found was a little odd because we know he has it because we just talked to him a
few minutes ago.
But besides the fact that you just talked to him a few minutes ago, as you stated
earlier, this is not his first rodeo.
No, I feel like he's learning a little bit.
Um, if that, he walks back out of the Chinese restaurant by himself, walks over.
He goes into the department store, goes into the department store is in the
department store again, three to five minutes at this time.
He starts, he's walking out with the female, you know, walking with them.
And we noticed on his way out of the department store, he's got, he's got a big
glass front display.
So he's walking out.
That cold open you saw: Bratton says officers watched through binoculars as the man
tipped over an ad display and pulled out what appeared to be a phone.
Hiding a phone under a display while two officers watch is a plan.
Next clip: listen for the words evasive action.
He pulls it out, puts a display back over and then sticks it in his pocket.
Then they continue walking out to the, out to the parking lot.
So they get into a gray car, which is the same car that officer Dick passed where he
thought, you know, he thought he saw him.
So it gets into the same car.
At this point, we pull, you know, we pull back out and we pull in front of their
car, you know, to get out and talk to them.
Phone seized. Now the unglamorous part.
Bratton says officers planned to seize the phone and get search warrants, which in
general practice is how phone contents are lawfully searched.
Next clip: listen for 75 pages and gigabytes.
Bratton says this paperwork can make or break a case.
Absolutely.
So at this point, at this point in the case, all the fun stuff's over with, we've
already got this.
So now we've got 75 pages of stuff off the phone and we've got data that gigabytes
worth of data that, you know, we just had to go through and put into a workable
format.
Um, so we do this stuff and basically we, we get the corroborating evidence that we
were looking for on the phone.
Um, likewise, we found.
This is Struggle Ash.
We break down cases so you know what not to do.
Subscribe - it's free, and better than a November Christmas-shopping alibi.
In order to legally hunt waterfowl in Virginia you have to have a plug in your
shotgun and
What the plug does is makes your shotgun not capable of holding more than three
shells so
Your average shotgun can hold without a plug and it could hold five some of them
even up to
Or more if they have an extended magazine what this plug does the plugs a removable
object that
You put in the magazine of the shotgun which prevents it from holding those full
five shells
What the law says, in plain English.
Bratton explains Virginia waterfowl hunters must use a plug limiting a shotgun to
three shells. Baiting means putting out feed to attract birds, and hunting over it
is a federal violation.
Hunting private land without permission is trespass.
General information, not advice about any case.
Um, you know, when we place.
Charges, you know, I've got a federal commission as well, but if I can work with the
local guys here, it makes it a lot more streamlined for us to, when we find
violations to streamline these charges and get them into the federal system.
It's just a lot easier, but on top of that, there's only two of us out there on the
Eastern shore.
So these federal guys are force multipliers for us.
We can't let the case in point of this.
I was 45 minutes away.
Lesson one: check the plug before you go.
Both guns here held five shells, and that's a violation.
Credit to the officers: Bratton called the nearest federal partner instead of
driving 35 minutes alone, and he says that partnership streamlines federal charges.
Check your gun in the truck, not in front of an officer.
Lesson two: get permission, and tips matter.
Hunt private land only with the owner's okay.
And if you see something wrong, report it.
Bratton says this whole case began with a landowner's phone call.
Alright, Y people and N people, here's how it went.
Like and subscribe for the next case.
Per Officer Bratton, the man faced state and federal charges, including hunting over
bait, and a judge extended his hunting revocation by five years on the state side.
Takeaway: paperwork beats denials.
Was waiting days to ask for his phone smart patience or a head start?



