Struggle Ash Subscribe

Home / Episodes / Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources

EX-006 · Game wardens

Game Warden Gets a Buck Screenshot, Pulls 3,700 Pages

How does one photo become a binder this thick?

Virginia Department of Wildlife ResourcesVirginiaNorthern Neck, Virginia11:57

Privacy-enhanced player. Nothing loads from YouTube until you press play. Open on YouTube

What happened

An anonymous tip with a screenshot of a big buck kicked off a months-long Virginia wildlife investigation in the Northern Neck. First Sergeant Amanda Nevel says the case grew to 3,700 pages of search-warrant returns, a literal crime board, and over 90 violations that she found. We break down how the tip became a joint search warrant with the Westmoreland County Sheriff's Office, what happened at the door, and what the Commonwealth's attorney moved forward with. We also cover game check systems, prosecution time limits, and why public posts become records. Credit: footage from the Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources' True Wildlife Crime podcast (released November 2025). To report a wildlife violation: https://dwr.virginia.gov/conservation-police/wildlife-violation/

The law in plain English

Game check and time limits

Hunters generally must report a harvest through the state's game-check system. Misdemeanors can have prosecution deadlines; Nevel cites one year. Search warrants generally require a judge's approval based on sworn facts. Rules vary by state and by charge, so this is general information, not legal advice.

General information, not legal advice. Whether a law applies to a given situation is for a court to decide.

Lessons

  1. Tips stretch thin patrols

    Nevel says she covers five counties alone, so tips from the public matter. If you see a wildlife violation, report it through your state agency's tip line or form.

  2. Posts become a timeline

    In this case, Nevel says public posts were matched against game-check records. What you post can be compared with official records later. Check your harvest in on time and keep your own records.

  3. Know boundaries and seasons

    Know whether land is public or private and whether you have permission. Seasons and legal weapons vary. Read your state's current regulations before every hunt, not just once a year.

Your call

First Sergeant Nevel paused the interview and left him with another officer for a smoke break while she checked the house. Smart reset or risky move?

Answer in the YouTube comments
Full transcript (225 lines)

One anonymous screenshot.

One very big buck that, per First Sergeant Amanda Nevel, wasn't in the game-check

system. Months later, a crowd of officers was at a door in the Northern Neck.

How does one photo become a binder this thick?

This person's name was not unknown to law enforcement.

Prediction time: does the suspect lose his hunting rights?

Comment Y for yes, N for no.

And smash like if you've ever lost a fight with paperwork.

What happened?

So we got an anonymous tip.

Somebody had sent me a screenshot, a picture of this subject with a very big buck.

So we looked it up in Go Outdoors, which is our game checking system, and it wasn't

checked in for the day, the week, anything during that timeframe.

Started monitoring the subject throughout the hunting season.

We got this, this was the end of November, early December of that season.

So we got a couple of weeks left.

We're almost done.

So we monitored him throughout the rest of the hunting season.

We're watching his behavior, see what's going on.

Step one was almost boring.

A screenshot of a big buck lands in Nevel's inbox, she looks in Go Outdoors, the

state's game-check system, and says nothing was logged for that timeframe.

Then comes the real skill: patience.

She says they monitored him for the rest of the season, then got search warrants for

phone and social media data.

Her superpower isn't a spidey sense.

It's a calendar. Next clip: listen for how many pages came back.

It was over 3,700 pages.

That we got back in the search warrant.

It took, I think two months to get all of the stuff back.

And then from there we turned into like Sherlock Holmes.

I mean, I had the full board and the pins and, and the pictures and all that stuff

Our office where we just tried to map out everything to show, okay, this is what he

Said on this social media.

And then when we check our accounts, it's not checked in for that whole week.

Cause I mean, people post stuff late, early.

Over 3,700 pages. Nevel says it took about two months for the warrant returns to

come back, and her answer was a real crime board with pins and pictures.

Her method, in her words: match what he posted against the check-in records, with a

couple of days' grace for people who post late.

Here's the timeline as she described it.

Next, watch the clip for what ended up in her binder.

So I went through and made literally a massive binder of every day and every

violation that we

So it was on this day, this person says they killed a deer.

Oh, if I go in our game check system, there's nothing checked in.

And then they admitted to using.

And then they admitted to using a Mossberg archery gun, which is a shotgun, not a

Okay.

And so now we're looking at shotgun during archery season.

So we're hunting during a closed season.

We failed to check the animal in.

We failed to tag the animal.

We're trespassing.

The binder was day by day: what he said, what the check system showed, and what he

admitted. Nevel says he admitted using a Mossberg archery gun, which she describes

as a shotgun, not a bow.

A shotgun in archery season is a bit like bringing a calculator to a spelling bee.

Her count: over 90 violations in one hunting season.

Next, watch the door and listen for his first words.

And he came out, we come over and explain it.

And his first words were like, what's, what's the game warden doing here?

Cause I mean, this is after the season.

This is several months after the season, the September, October timeframe.

I forget.

And so he had no idea we were coming.

He's been digging through all this stuff.

He doesn't know you've been digging through it through the off season.

Correct.

And, and now what the heck?

Yeah, here we are.

We pull them out, explain everything, separate him to do an interview with him,

"What's the game warden doing here?" Nevel says that was his first reaction, months

after the season ended.

Her team separated him for an interview, put another officer with the girlfriends,

and sent a team inside.

What officers did well: she says they briefed the Westmoreland County Sheriff's

Office first and went in as a joint task force.

Next clip: listen for her line about eight o'clock.

So he was definitely lying and being evasive, not telling anything the truth in the

beginning.

Uh, but once he told the first line, I could show him the evidence and the

information

That I had, you know, explain that I don't just randomly knock on people's doors at

O'clock in the morning.

Like we're here for a reason.

Uh, I think it, it kind of sunk in that, you know, we were, this was real, this was

happening

And we weren't just asking questions that we didn't already know the answers to.

Here's the interview tactic, and it's old but good: lead with evidence.

Nevel says he was evasive at first.

Evasion versus a binder is not a fair fight.

In the next clip, listen for how she describes her preparation.

Those are her words, not ours.

I mean, in this case, like I said, we had so much evidence coming in that if he

I knew it.

Cause I had, you know, I've never been so prepared for an interview in my life.

I had so much data coming in here that it was easy to say, no, you're lying and show

It to him.

And then you got nothing to do, but tell me the truth.

Now we play this one straight.

Nevel went inside mid-interview and was warned about safety hazards in the house.

Listen to the next clip for what she says officers did about the children and

animals there.

The refrigerator.

There's a carpet over a hole in the floor and we almost lost an officer.

So there's a literal cartoon, like a Scooby-Doo moment where somebody is literally

going to

Get sucked into the floor.

Yes.

Okay.

So that was unsafe.

Slightly.

Uh, there's full gallons of water all across the countertop cause the water wasn't

working.

It's in a low point of the, of the, I don't want to say marsh cause it's dry land,

It was in a low point of the property.

And so the septic wasn't working well.

So then I was also told the septic was backing up and to not go into the bathroom.

So it was a lot of concerns for children being in the house.

What the team did well: when they saw the conditions, they flagged outside agencies

instead of just collecting antlers.

Then the haul. Nevel says they seized antlers, trail cameras, and his phone, and

passed drug-related items to the sheriff's office.

One decision a viewer could question: she left him with another officer for a smoke

break mid-interview.

Watch what she says happened next.

It found a lot of, um, the antlers that we were looking for that had come out

The social media posts and everything.

So we confiscated all the illegal antlers.

There were some trail cameras we confiscated to, uh, pull, get search boards for, to

The pictures and stuff off of that.

Uh, there was some drug paraphernalia and other stuff that we found that was, uh, we

Turned over to West Berlin sheriff's office to deal with appropriately.

And did you, um, did you confiscate his phone or any phones that were there?

Yeah, we confiscated his phone to be turned in for a search warrant and data search.

They're in there doing all of that.

I stepped back out.

We continue the interview and he is much more honest this time.

On the second round, Nevel says he was much more honest.

Her read is that the break gave him time to think.

Maybe it was the pause, maybe it was the pile of evidence, and the footage can't

settle that. Next, listen for what else the data mining spun off.

Yeah.

And it, uh, um, it kind of led us down a wormhole or rabbit hole, if you will.

Um.

So it had, we had spent off cases that were related to this one because of all the

Mining and stuff we had done.

So we were able to come up with other cases where people had killed stuff out of

season,

Failed to check stuff in, uh, felons with firearms, all this, all these other

avenues

That were spun out of this one.

So it just kept getting bigger and bigger.

You're watching Struggle Ash - we dissect real law enforcement footage so you learn

what not to do. Subscribe, the lessons are free, the binders optional.

Well, so we have a year to prosecute misdemeanors.

So that kind of put our timeline on us.

Because at this point, this entire case is officer's warrant stuff.

So he doesn't know that we're looking at him.

He doesn't know that we're been working in for three or four months at this point.

He has no idea that we're coming.

Wow.

So you, at this point, this is all data driven, doing your homework, getting all

your ducks

In a row.

Just so.

Two concepts. First, game check: hunters generally report a harvest to the state's

system, so a photo with no matching record can prompt questions.

Check your state's exact rules.

Second, time limits: Nevel says Virginia misdemeanors have a one-year window to

prosecute, which set her clock.

And search warrants generally need a judge's approval, which is why her paperwork

mattered. General information, not advice.

So in reference to the cases that you've worked, tips, how important are they when

they lead to something like this?

Well, they're super important.

Cause it could be, I mean, we can't be everywhere.

I'm one person working in five district, I'm in five counties in my district.

So I can't be everywhere at once.

There's only one of us.

We're not like the localities that have 20 officers work in the streets.

There's one of us.

So there's a lot of territory to cover.

So we rely on the tip line, rely on sources and friends of conservation that want to

Reach out and help us do our job basically, because we need wildlife ambassadors in

Lesson one: officers can't be everywhere.

Nevel says she's one officer covering five counties, so tips from the public matter.

If you see a wildlife violation, the reporting link is in the description.

Next clip: watch how the team structure works.

So we met with Westmoreland County Sheriff's Office, where all of these crimes had

Place and met with them and briefed them on what was going on.

So when we went in to do the search warrant for the actual residents, they came with

So we had a joint task force with Westmoreland Sheriff's Office.

Lesson two: posts are records.

Nevel says public social media posts were matched against check-in data, one date at

a time. Anything you post can help build a timeline.

Next clip: listen for how she describes public versus private land.

Or rabbit holes, whatever you want to call them to figure out like who these people

How everything connected to the community and where we had permission to hunt, where

We didn't have permission to hunt what's public property, what's private property.

Lesson three: know the lines.

Nevel mentions public versus private property, permission to hunt, and those

invisible lines in the woods.

Hunters generally need permission on private land, and seasons and weapon types

matter. Check your state's regulations before you go.

Next clip: one officer doing everything.

So we're, uh, a state department, but we're smaller than some of the localities in

Aspect that we are the one person doing everything.

We don't have like a, an evident tech that's going to log all the evidence.

Like we're doing all of those steps.

Alright, Y people and N people, here's how it went.

Like and subscribe for the next case, we've got more binders where this came from.

He was put on probation.

Uh, he did ASAP and was done through some drug substance abuse programs.

At the end of that year, he lost his hunting license for another five years as a

Of the deal.

Okay.

So that's $1,000 in replacement costs and forfeiture of all the antlers that we had

Seized during the search warrant.

Per Virginia DWR's podcast, the Commonwealth's attorney pursued 17 charges;

penalties included a year of lost hunting rights, probation, $1,000 replacement

costs, antler forfeiture, and five more license-less years.

Takeaway: records outlast stories.

Did Nevel's mid-interview smoke break for him help or hurt the case?

Related episodes